No apologies for returning to the campaign to protect bass stocks in the UK. The Angling Trust continues to work with our colleagues in the Bass Anglers Sportfishing Society (B.A.S.S.) to persuade our politicians of the plight of of British bass and the need for action, not just at a European level but in our inshore waters as well.
We have been well supported in these efforts by prominent figures in the bass world including Matt Powell from Wales and Henry Gilbey whose recently wrote a great blogpost which you can find here:
Successive Fisheries Ministers from both sides of politics have been well aware of the increasingly parlous state of bass numbers and the long overdue need for the introduction of measures to prevent a catastrophic stock collapse. Sadly, it now seems that this collapse could be about to happen. The results from the recent Solent bass survey in the English Channel confirm that there have been five poor year classes in a row (2008 – 2012) which offers a bleak prospect for the future.
With the exception of Labour’s Ben Bradshaw, who tried unsuccessfully to raise the ridiculously inadequate bass minimum landing size (mls), and the Conservative’s Richard Benyon, who instigated the current mls review, other ministers have been reluctant to either heed the warnings or follow scientific advice. This is partly because the commercial sector consistently sets it’s face against any restrictions on their activities and they are effective lobbyists to which politicians have become accustomed to listening. However, we are hoping that the current incumbent, George Eustice, will be prepared to finally grasp the nettle and introduce long overdue conservation measures for this most iconic of sportfish.
The reason we are now in this unhappy place is because for the last 10 years our politicians have been ignoring the evidence from the International Council for the Exploration of the Seas (ICES) and their own scientists and listening to the loudest and most self-interested voices. The scientific advice from ICES in 2013 for a 36% cut in total catches was not acted upon and now the latest recommendation is for an 80% cut in catches of bass across the EU in 2015. Increasing commercial fishing effort and successive years of recruitment failure are cumulatively driving bass stocks towards a precipice. Unless action is taken immediately to protect the remaining stock a total moratorium on bass fishing in Europe will soon be the only option available to protect and restore this important fishery.
A collapse in bass stocks or a total moratorium on all forms of bass fishing would be disastrous for recreational sea angling which, according to Defra’s own Sea Angling 2012 report shows there are 884,000 sea anglers in England who directly pump £1.23 billion p.a. into the economy and upon which 10,400 full time jobs are dependent. If induced and indirect impacts are taken into account these figures soar to £2.1 billion and 23,600 jobs. The VAT alone which is collected from sea anglers dwarfs the entire value of all commercial fish landings in England. In purely economic terms, we would be better off if bass were retained as a line caught species only with the bulk of the market demand met by farmed fish. This would immediately revive the UK fishery for both the inshore under ten metre commercial fleet, who would be in position to provide a premium product caught in a sustainable way, and the recreational sector – the majority of whom practice catch and release.
Will Europe Deliver?
Despite some encouraging signs that the European Commission has finally woken up to the unfolding disaster that is happening across the North Atlantic Fishery we remain concerned that their proposals will inevitably get watered down once the commercials get to work on their individual parliamentarians. A number of welcome measures are on the table at the moment and relate to the main bass stock in the Celtic sea, Channel, Irish Sea and North Sea. The interested Member States (i.e. France, UK, Netherlands, Ireland, Belgium, Spain and Portugal) agreed on the following key factors:
- acceptance of the assessment of the state of the stock;
- a total allowable catch (TAC) not being the best option;
- the need for immediate action to reduce fishing mortality significantly, with specific limits on targeted fisheries, both commercial and recreational;
- the need to protect spawning aggregation areas;
- the need to take into account socio-economic factors; and,
- beyond immediate action the need in the medium term for a management plan.
There is no doubt that Mr Eustice’s fisheries officials at Defra are pushing hard for conservation measures at a European level. In recent correspondence they said:
This consensus is important as it now paves the way for action to be taken forward by the Commission, with the intention of including proposals in the Fishing Opportunities Regulation for 2015 for agreement at December Council. There is still further discussion expected with the Commission on whether the restrictions on commercial vessels will include entry and effort limits or catch limits for vessels, the latter being preferred by the UK.
In addition, the Commission indicated that it would want to provide for closed fishing seasons for the commercial sector, and will be exploring the best legislative means to do so promptly for 2015.
This should mean closing the main spawning aggregation areas in South West waters to directed fisheries, consequently ending the pair trawl fishery during the spring months, targeted fishing which alone accounts for 25% of the EU catch.
The Commission is also likely to propose catch limits for recreational fisheries (e.g. bag limits).
Most of the interested Member States already have some sort of bag limit. An EU standard would, we think, be a new approach and an appropriate level would need to be set, for example, we have an estimate that a two fish bag limit per fisherman a day would reduce the UK recreational take by a third.
In my view this is good stuff but how much of it will survive the inevitable political trade-offs remains to be seen. That’s why both B.A.S.S. and the Angling Trust are pushing hard for the UK to adopt a management plan for bass in our territorial waters. After all, this is primarily an inshore species and other EU countries such as the Netherlands and Ireland have introduced bass minimum landing sizes and other management measures rather than leaving it all to Europe. Unfortunately, ‘leaving it to Europe’ has been our own government’s preferred position up until now but there’s some signs of a welcome shift. At a recent Angling Summit at Defra we challenged George Eustice and showed how reports from his own scientists demonstrated that bass displayed considerable site fidelity and that domestic technical measures could make a real difference.
These results, taken with those of an earlier study on the recruitment patterns of bass from UK nursery areas (Pickett et al., 2004), suggest that the main benefits (in terms of yield) of management aimed at protecting juvenile sea bass in coastal waters of England and Wales accrue chiefly to fisheries operating within the UK 6-mile zone. (Pawson et al 2007)
This is why now is the right time for everyone who cares about the future of this wonderful fish to to pick up a pen or start tapping on a keyboard in order to let our MPs know that we are expecting to see action to save British bass stocks, not just in Europe but here at home. We have made it as easy as possible for anglers to get involved with a special Fishing Lines briefing on bass conservation from the Angling Trust and a draft letter to MPs which can be downloaded from our website here:
Letter template – http://bit.ly/basstemplate
Fishing Lines briefing – http://bit.ly/bassbriefing
In addition it would be helpful to remind the government of what their own officials are saying about UK bass management measures:
George Eustice’s confirmation of the previous Ministerial undertaking to review the domestic minimum landing size for bass still stands in this regard in recent correspondence. Against the background of EU developments our domestic management role remains particularly important in consideration of the site fidelity characteristics of bass, meaning local management will make a key contribution.
To make a difference we need thousands of letters and emails from concerned anglers pressing parliamentarians to raise the issue with the Fisheries Ministers and to table parliamentary questions demanding action to save our bass. Most importantly we need an immediate increase in the current minimum landing size from 36cms to 45 – 48cms in order to allow bass to successfully reach their initial spawning size of 42cms and to complete their life cycles. Many of us would like to go further with the introduction of slot size limits to protect the bigger, more fertile, trophy fish which are of such value to any fishery. We also want to press for an end to commercial harvesting during the spring spawning period, restrictions on pairs trawling and trammel netting, which have done so much damage already, and for a significant expansion in estuarine bass nursery areas where juvenile fish can be afforded greater protection.
It would be great if you joined the Angling Trust and B.A.S.S. in order to contribute to the fight to save our bass but if you do nothing else this week please at least find ten minutes to download the info and ping off some choice words to your local MP.
You can get their details from: http://www.parliament.uk/mps-lords-and-offices/mps/
To join the Angling Trust go to: http://www.anglingtrust.net/page.asp?section=32§ionTitle=Join+Angling+Trust
And for B.A.S.S. go to: http://www.ukbass.com/join-us/
Remember – our bass are in trouble and they need all the help we can give !
2 thoughts on “Save our Bass – Time to contact your MP”
‘We also want to press for an end to commercial harvesting during the spring spawning period, restrictions on pairs trawling and trammel netting, which have done so much damage already,’ Yes please about time this was stopped especially the pair trawling, it would be interesting to know the amount of discards and by-catch from all trawlers.
And a significant expansion in estuarine bass nursery areas where juvenile fish can be afforded greater protection.’ sorry but this has failed in Milford Haven nursery areas where the hypocrisy of stopping commercial fishermen entering these areas whilst allowing pleasure anglers and holidaymakers to RAPE the bass stocks and sell their catches!!! ALL ANGLING SHOULD BE BANNED IN THESE AREAS FROM SHORE AND BOAT AND A £5000 FINE FOR ANYONE FLAUNTING THE RULING. When I complained about this to the South and South West Wales Sea Fisheries Authority this is allowed due to tourism being damaged by fishing bans.
Being a salmon angler for 35 years welcoming and adhering to the early season catch & release laws ( all salmon to be released before July 1st) maybe bass anglers should practice catch and release for all fish caught and stop the hypocricy between commercial and pleasure angling.
Save our bass before it’s too late let’s not lose the most beautiful fish in the sea .Next in decline is the mackerel
.Then the Cod and it goes on .Unless
we act now.